Reliability of Different Methods for Measuring Stress Radiographs in Posterior Cruciate Ligament Insufficiency

Main Article Content

Sukrom Cheecharern
Pinij Srisuwanporn
Chaiwat Lorpongpaiboon

Abstract

Aims: This study aims to assess the intraobserver and interobserver reliability of various measurement methods of stress radiographs in PCL insufficiency.

Study Design: Descriptive study.

Place and Duration of Study: Department of Orthopaedics, at Rajavithi Hospital, Bangkok between December 2015 and June 2016.

Methodology: Three measurement methods including Mid-Mid Method, Blumensaat's Line-Posterior Tibia Method and Blumensaat's Line-Anterior Tibia Method were employed. Each technique performed twice by two orthopaedic surgeons. Patients were assessed at day 0 and at 4 weeks. Intrarater and interrater reliability of measurements in PCL Radiographs were observed.

Results: The findings indicate that the Blumensaat's line-posterior tibia method showed the highest intraobserver reliability. For intrarater agreement, each method produced high correlation (r > 0.9) at both week 0 and 4. Regarding interrater agreement between two surgeons, high correlation (r > 0.8) was found in Mid-Mid Method and Blumensaat's Line-Posterior Tibia Method, while the Blumensaat's Line-Anterior Tibia method gave medium level of correlation (r=0.528-0.675). Both surgeons indicated similar results for each pair of measurement. The Mid-Mid Method and Blumensaat's Line-Posterior Tibia Method showed positive correlation of measurement. Mid-Mid Method and Blumensaat's Line-Anterior Tibia Method, and Blumensaat's Line-Posterior Tibia Method and Blumensaat's Line-Anterior Tibia Method showed negative correlation of measurement.

Conclusion: The Blumensaat's line-anterior tibia method produced the highest intraobserver and interobserver reliability in measuring stress radiographs in posterior cruciate ligament insufficiency.

Keywords:
Stress radiograph, posterior cruciate ligament, Blumensaat's line-posterior tibia, Blumensaat's line-anterior tibia

Article Details

How to Cite
Cheecharern, S., Srisuwanporn, P., & Lorpongpaiboon, C. (2020). Reliability of Different Methods for Measuring Stress Radiographs in Posterior Cruciate Ligament Insufficiency. Asian Journal of Orthopaedic Research, 3(4), 6-12. Retrieved from https://journalajorr.com/index.php/AJORR/article/view/30126
Section
Original Research Article

References

Fanelli GC, Edson CJ. Posterior cruciate ligament injuries in trauma patients: Part II. Arthroscopy. 1995;11(5):526–9.

Margheritini F, Mancini L, Mauro CS, Mariani PP. Stress Radiography for Quantifying Posterior Cruciate Ligament Deficiency. Arthroscopy. 2003;19(7):706-11.

Srisuwanporn P, Wachiratarapadorn S, Panyasakulwong R, Thuntong B, Cheecharern S, Precha W. Accuracy of a New Stress Radiographic Device in Diagnosing Anterior Cruciate Ligament Tear. J Med Assoc Thai. 2016;99(4):394- 399.

Cheecharern S, Panyasakulwong R, Laksawut S, Lorpongpaiboon C, Thuntong B, Srisuwasnporn P, et al. Correlation between a stress radiographic device and MRI in posterior cruciate ligament tears. J Med Assoc Thai. 2019;102(3):291-7.

Jackman T, LaPrade RF, Pontinen T, Lender PA. Intraobserver and interobserver reliability of the kneeling technique of stress radiography for the evaluation of posterior knee laxity. Am J Sports Med. 2008;36(8):1571–6.

Schulz MS, Russe K, Lampakis G, Strobel MJ. Reliability of stress radiography for evaluation of posterior knee laxity. Am J Sports Med. 2005;33:502-6.

Wirz P, von Stokar P, Jakob RP. The effect of knee position on the reproducibility of measurements taken from stress films: A comparison of four measurement methods. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2000;8:143-8.

Jacobsen K. Stress radiographical measurements of post-traumatic knee instability: A clinical study. Acta Orthop Scand. 1977;48:301-10.

Staubli HU, Jakob RP. Posterior instability of the knee near extension: A clinical and stress radiographic analysis of acute injuries of the posterior cruciate ligament. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1990;72(2):225-30.

Hewett TE, Noyes FR, Lee MD. Diagnosis of complete and partial posterior cruciate ligament ruptures: Stress radiography compared with KT-1000 arthrometer and posterior drawer testing. Am J Sport Med. 1997;25:648-55.

Daniel DM, Stone ML, Barnett P, Sachs R. Use of the quadriceps active test to diagnose posterior cruciate-ligament disruption and measure posterior laxity of the knee. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1988; 70(3):386-91.

Lee YS, Han SH, Jo J, Kwak KS, Nha KW, Kim JH. Comparison of 5 different methods for measuring stress radiographs to improve reproducibility during the evaluation of knee instability. Am J Sport Med 2011;39(6):1275-81.